Political integrity and dirty hands: compromise and the ambiguities of betrayal

Tillyris, D. (2017) Political integrity and dirty hands: compromise and the ambiguities of betrayal. Res Publica, 23 (4). pp. 475-494. ISSN 1356-4765.

15178.pdf - Accepted Version

Download (358kB) | Preview


The claim that democratic politics is the art of compromise is a platitude but we seem allergic to compromise in politics when it happens. This essay explores this paradox. Taking my cue from Machiavelli’s claim that there exists a rift between a morally admirable and a virtuous political life I argue that: i) a ‘compromising disposition’ is an ambiguous virtue – something which is politically expedient but not necessarily morally admirable; ii) whilst uncongenial to moral integrity, a ‘compromising disposition’ constitutes an essential part of political integrity. In so doing, I question certain moralistic assumptions which fuel contemporary vilifications of compromise – that, in theory, democratic politics should be inhospitable to compromise and that political integrity should be akin to moral integrity – and which are shared by Walzer’s Dirty Hands thesis which professes to be sensitive to the realities of politics. These assumptions displace the complex realities of politics and misconstrue the standards of political excellence; they unsatisfactorily idealize political integrity and the messy context in which democratic politicians operate – a context characterized by a plurality of incompatible traditions, each with its own values and principles. Whilst commitment to a set of principles stemming from one's tradition or pre-election promises implies commitment to realize these, leading a virtuous political life amidst such a grubby domain often requires abandoning some of these. An innocent, all-or-nothing pursuit of one's principles in politics might prompt political disaster or defeat: an uncompromising disposition entails the entire abandonment of any hope of realizing all of those principles.

Item Type: Article
Uncontrolled Keywords: Compromise; political integrity; dirty hands; democratic politics; moral conflict; betrayal
Subjects: B Philosophy. Psychology. Religion > BJ Ethics > BJ0001 Ethics (General) > BJ1518 Individual ethics. Character. Virtue
B Philosophy. Psychology. Religion > BJ Ethics > BJ0001 Ethics (General) > BJ1725 Ethics of social groups, classes, etc. Professional ethics
J Political Science > JA Political science (General)
J Political Science > JC Political theory
Divisions: Faculty of Social and Applied Sciences > School of Psychology, Politics and Sociology
Depositing User: Demetris Tillyris
Date Deposited: 29 Nov 2016 14:41
Last Modified: 07 Feb 2019 15:46
URI: https://create.canterbury.ac.uk/id/eprint/15178

Actions (login required)

Update Item (CReaTE staff only) Update Item (CReaTE staff only)


Downloads per month over past year

View more statistics


Connect with us

Last edited: 29/06/2016 12:23:00